Solid surface countertops are made using synthetic materials. They’re growing in popularity owing to their many advantages, including being non-porous and homogenous. These properties make solid surface countertops a sanitary and hygienic option that doesn’t harbor bacteria or support the growth of mold and mildew. They’re an ideal choice for kitchens, bathrooms, labs, and doctor’s offices.
They’re also aesthetically pleasing due to their ability to mimic different materials and have almost invisible seams. Solid surface counters are an affordable alternative to natural stone countertops such as granite, marble, and quartzite, which perform better than laminate. Unlike laminate, solid surface countertops are stable and have more visual depth even after impact.
However, you should understand all the drawbacks of this material before you pick. Learn about the main disadvantages of solid surface countertops to help you decide whether they’re the best choice for your home.
The Construction of Solid Surface Countertops
Understanding the construction of solid surface countertops can help you understand their drawbacks. Solid surface countertops are made using resins and minerals. The most commonly used resins include acrylic, plastic and polyester, while the most common minerals are marble, granite, and quartzite. The minerals also vary depending on the desired final look of the countertop.
Solid surface countertops generally contain 66% minerals and 33% binding agents. Pigments and powdered fillers are also added to mimic the look and feel of natural stone or wood. The pigments allow the customization of colors, patterns, and textures. Solid surface countertops can be buffed to a matte finish or polished to a high gloss.
The Disadvantages of Solid Surface Countertops
While solid surface countertops provide homeowners with many benefits, they have numerous disadvantages that may make them unreliable. Here are the top cons of solid surface counters:
1. Susceptible to Scratching
One of the main disadvantages of solid surface countertops is that they are softer than natural stone. This makes them more susceptible to scratches caused by knives and other sharp utensils. The scratches appear white on the surface, especially against darker-colored solid surface countertops. Therefore, it’s better to use lighter-colored solid surface countertops in high-traffic areas. Whatever color you choose, always use a cutting board to prevent scratches and cuts.
Fortunately, solid surface countertops can be resurfaced by sanding them down using a scouring pad, fine-grit sandpaper, or an orbital sander, depending on the depth of the scratch or cut. Regular polishing and refinishing are necessary to maintain the appearance of your countertops.
You can save time and money spent polishing and refinishing solid surface countertops by picking natural stone countertops instead. Natural stone countertops last a lifetime and require minimal maintenance. For instance, quartzite and granite do not easily scratch, chip or break, even with decades of use.
2. Sensitive to Heat
The soft nature of solid surface countertops makes them susceptible to heat deformation. They can typically withstand a boiling water temperature of 212°F but start to deform at temperatures exceeding 250°F. This means placing hot pans directly on the counter can cause discoloration, cracks, and scorching.
You can prevent damage to solid surface countertops by always placing your pots and pans on trivets and heat pads. Conversely, granite countertops can withstand temperatures of up to 1,200°F.
3. Requires Regular Maintenance and Repairs
Careful use and regular maintenance of solid counter surfaces are necessary to keep them in pristine condition. The following are some care and maintenance tips for solid surface countertops:
- Wipe up spills immediately to prevent water damage and stains.
- Use cutting boards and avoid chopping or cutting food directly on the countertops.
- Do not pull hard and heavy objects across the surface.
- Use soft cleaning tools, like sponges and microfiber cloths, to wipe the surfaces.
- Use mild dish soap or ammonia-based cleaners to remove dirt, dust, and build-up on the countertops.
Conversely, natural stone countertops allow stress-free use of your space because of their minimal maintenance needs. For example, granite and quartzite countertops withstand heavy-duty use and are easy to clean with simple household solutions. Additionally, you can’t cut through them easily and they have better resistance to heat, moisture and stains.
4. Vulnerable to Stains and Chemicals
While solid surface countertops are relatively stain-resistant, strong chemicals can permanently stain or damage them. Avoid using paint thinners, nail polish remover, and other strong chemicals on the countertops.
They are also susceptible to damage from abrasive cleansers and harsh chemical cleaners. If you choose solid surface counters, stick to using gentle pH-balanced cleaners or mild soapy water to clean them and maintain their aesthetics and durability.
In contrast, natural stone countertops are more resistant to chemicals and abrasive cleaners because they’re dense and less porous. You can increase the stain resistance of granite or marble countertops by sealing them with a waterproof, non-toxic and food-safe sealer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are the answers to a few more common questions about solid surface and natural stone counters:
How Long Do Solid Surface Countertops Last?
Most solid surface countertops come with a 10-year warranty, which they outlive when they’re used, cleaned and maintained as intended. Solid surface countertops are renewable and repairable so you can extend the life span to 30 or 50 years.
Which Is Better — Solid Surface vs. Granite?
Solid surface is an affordable alternative to granite, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners looking for an attractive and durable countertop option. However, granite countertops are a premium alternative to solid surface countertops that are resistant to heat, water, stains, scratching and chipping. Granite also adds considerable value to your home and kitchen.
Why Is Natural Stone Better?
Natural stone is an excellent countertop material that adds a unique and timeless appearance and boosts the value of your home. In comparison, solid surface countertops don’t add any value to your home, but they don’t detract from its resale value. Natural stone is more durable and performs better against heat, moisture, stains, cuts, and scratches.
Get High-Quality Solid Surface Countertops From Lesher Marble
Despite the many disadvantages of solid surface countertops, they’re still a reliable option for homeowners on a budget. However, if you’re not on a tight budget, you have many other superior-quality countertop options. At Lesher Natural Stone, Quartz, & Tile, we offer a wide selection of beautiful natural stone countertops.
Our inventory includes marble, granite, and quartzite countertops precisely cut to your specific dimensions. We’ll fabricate the countertops, deliver them, and match you with expert installers. Request a quote for your natural stone countertops.
